Firefighter Rescues Four Off Vineyard

By Norman Miller
May 20, 2002
The MetroWest Daily News


Framingham firefighter Edward Lill knows he has to be ready at a moment's notice to respond to any emergency when he's at work.

But yesterday morning, he and his two friends, Michael Guerrieri and Ken Moscatelli, were fishing near the Elizabeth Islands at Martha's Vineyard when they were called to action to save four men whose boat had sunk.

"Everything happened so quick and so smooth," said Lill, a 21-year veteran of the department. "I can feel good about it. The three of us kept level heads. We were under control. We didn't panic."

At about 8 a.m., Lill of Ashland, with Guerrieri of Bourne and Moscatelli of Sagamore, were fishing for stripers on Lill's 21-foot Carolina Skip, the Three Amigos.

Because of large 2- to 4-foot waves, the men fished with the engine off.

In the distance, about 75 yards away, Lill said he saw a man waving his hands "frantically" while another bailed out a 20-foot Wellcraft.

"You could see they were distressed," said Lill. "Before we could say another word, the boat began to sink. We began to head over there, and within 30 seconds, their boat was completely sunk. It was gone."

When Lill and his friends neared where the boat had been, they found four men clinging to a 100-quart cooler in the cold and rough seas.

Guerrieri threw a rope to the men, and they pulled all of them to the side of the boat, Lill said.

That, Lill said, is when it became tricky. His boat isn't meant to hold seven people.

"There were three of us on the boat, and four of them on the side," Lill said. "They were out there, and they were so tired. They were only there for three or four minutes, and they were exhausted. You could see symptoms of hypothermia were setting in. They weren't in shock, but they were on their way.

"We took them up one at a time," continued Lill. "We instructed them to get on the other side of the boat so it wouldn't capsize. When we got the last one in, he was completely exhausted. He even said he couldn't move, we had to help him up."

The three friends brought the other men to the Coast Guard station in Woods Hole. The rescued men's boat had been hit by two large waves, which caused it to sink, Lill said.

A spokesman for the Coast Guard said he had no information about the rescue except to confirm it had happened. The state Environmental Police are handling the investigation, and they could not be reached for comment.

Although he deals with emergency situations on a daily basis, Lill said yesterday's incident was different than the ones he usually sees.

"When you get called for a medical or a heart attack, it has already happened - you don't see it," said Lill. "I saw this happen."

It was lucky for the four men that he and his friends did see the boat sink, Lill said. Several other boats closer than them did not.

"We weren't even the closest boat," said Lill. "(The rescued men) didn't even know we were there, they weren't facing us. We were a good 50 to 75 yards away. There were other boats that were closer, but if you weren't facing the right way, you wouldn't even notice if they were there. With the wind kicked up like that and the waves, it's hard to hear a distress call."

This wasn't the first time Lill was involved in an ocean rescue. Two years ago, he and Moscatelli rescued a couple in Sandwich while they kayaked in Scorten Creek, which flows into the ocean.

"The woman flipped her kayak, and she couldn't get upright," said Lill. "Her husband had dove in to help, but they got caught in a rip tide, and pulled out. We plucked them out of the water."

After the three friends left Woods Hole yesterday, they headed out to fish for more stripers, but it wasn't the same.

"We went back out, but we didn't fish as hard as before," Lill said. "The people we rescued, the cooler they were holding onto had three keeper stripers. It was a very good day.

Return to Spotlight Index